[
ABSTRAKPendahuluan
Penegakkan diagnosis gangguan bipolar sering mengalami kesulitan kerena
adanya komorbiditas yang mengakibatkan gejala pada gangguan bipolar tidak
menonjol. Tumpang tindih gejala pada gangguan bipolar dengan gangguan jiwa
lainnya menyebabkan terjadinya ketidaktepatan diagnosis sehingga orang dengan
gangguan bipolar didiagnosis sebagai gangguan jiwa lainnya pada pemeriksaan
awal. Data dari National Depressive and Manic Depressive Association
(NDMDA) menunjukan 60% gangguan bipolar didiagnosis depresi, 26% anxietas,
18% skizofrenia, 17% gangguan kepribadian borderline atau antisosial, 14%
penyalahgunaan alkohol dan 11% skizoafektif. Sekitar 69%-73% pasien dengan
gangguan bipolar mengalami ketidaktepatan diagnosis pada saat pemeriksaan
awal. Peneliti ingin mengetahui besaran komorbiditas pada penderita gangguan
bipolar dan hubungannya dengan ketidaktepatan diagnosis pada gangguan bipolar.
Metode
Studi ini merupakan penelitian deskriptif analitik dengan rancangan potong
lintang. Responden adalah pasien dewasa di RSUPN dr Cipto Mangunkusumo
Jakarta dan RS dr. Marzoeki Mahdi Bogor pada bulan Desember 2014 hingga
didapatkan jumlah sampel, yaitu 80 responden. Pasien yang berobat dan terlihat
adanya gejala mood dilakukan pemeriksaan dari rekam medis dan pemeriksaan
dengan instrumen SCID I.
Hasil
Didapatkan 80 responden dengan gangguan bipolar, pada studi rekam medis
diketahui ada 11 responden (13.8%) yang didiagnosis bukan sebagai gangguan
bipolar setelah rutin mendapatkan perawatan medis. Diketahui juga ada 62.5%
dari seluruh responden yang memiliki komorbid. Berdasarkan analisis
menggunakan SPSS versi 20 didapatkan hasil adanya hubungan yang bermakna
antara komorbid dengan terjadinya ketidaktepatan diagnosis gangguan bipolar
dengan nilai p 0.046.
Simpulan
Pada penelitian ini instrumen SCID I digunakan sebagai standar baku emas untuk
menegakkan diagnosis gangguan bipolar dan mengetahui adanya komorbid.
Berdasarkan hasil penelitian ini didapatkan 13.8% responden yang didiagnosis
bukan sebagai gangguan bipolar walaupun telah rutin mendapatkan perawatan
medis. Terdapat hubungan antara kejadian komorbid dengan ketidaktepatan
diagnosis gangguan bipolar.
ABSTRACTBackground
Diagnosing Bipolar Disorder often times has become difficult due to
comorbidities causing indistinct features emerging from the disorder.
Overlapping of bipolar disorder with other psychiatric disorders leads to
inaccuracy since the beginning of diagnosis. Thus people with bipolar disorder
has been diagnosed with other disorders previously.Data fromNational
Depressive and Manic Depressive Association (NDMDA) shows 60% of bipolar
disorder being diagnosed with depression, 26% with anxiety, 18% with
skizofrenia 17% with borderline or antisocial personality disorder, 14% with
alcohol abuse and 11%with schizoaffective. Approximately 69%-73% patients
with bipolar disorder experienced inaccuracy of diagnosis in the beginning.The
author would like to find comorbidities of people with bipolar disorder and its
relationship with misdiagnosis of bipolar diagnosis.
Method
This is an analytic descriptive study with cross sectional in design. Respondents
are adults patients at National Referal Hospital of dr Cipto Mangunkusumo in
Jakarta and dr. Marzoeki Mahdi Hospital in Bogor on Desember 2014, and a
total of 80 samples were acquired. Patients on medication and observed to be
with mood symptoms were performed evaluation from medical record and SCID 1
instrument.
Result
From medical record evaluation, 11 (13.8%) out 80 respondents with bipolar
disorder were found to be diagnosed with other than bipolar disorder after
routine medical treatment. This study found 62.5% from all respondents to have
comorbidities. Analysis using SPSS version 20 revealed significant relationship
between comorbidities with misdiagnosis of bipolar disorder (p 0.046).
Conclusion
This study used SCID I instrument as gold standard in diagnosing bipolar
disorder and to find comorbidities. 13.8% respondents were found to be
diagnosed with other than bipolar disorder even after routine medical treatment.
There is a relationship between comorbidity with misdiagnosis of bipolar
disorder.;Background
Diagnosing Bipolar Disorder often times has become difficult due to
comorbidities causing indistinct features emerging from the disorder.
Overlapping of bipolar disorder with other psychiatric disorders leads to
inaccuracy since the beginning of diagnosis. Thus people with bipolar disorder
has been diagnosed with other disorders previously.Data fromNational
Depressive and Manic Depressive Association (NDMDA) shows 60% of bipolar
disorder being diagnosed with depression, 26% with anxiety, 18% with
skizofrenia 17% with borderline or antisocial personality disorder, 14% with
alcohol abuse and 11%with schizoaffective. Approximately 69%-73% patients
with bipolar disorder experienced inaccuracy of diagnosis in the beginning.The
author would like to find comorbidities of people with bipolar disorder and its
relationship with misdiagnosis of bipolar diagnosis.
Method
This is an analytic descriptive study with cross sectional in design. Respondents
are adults patients at National Referal Hospital of dr Cipto Mangunkusumo in
Jakarta and dr. Marzoeki Mahdi Hospital in Bogor on Desember 2014, and a
total of 80 samples were acquired. Patients on medication and observed to be
with mood symptoms were performed evaluation from medical record and SCID 1
instrument.
Result
From medical record evaluation, 11 (13.8%) out 80 respondents with bipolar
disorder were found to be diagnosed with other than bipolar disorder after
routine medical treatment. This study found 62.5% from all respondents to have
comorbidities. Analysis using SPSS version 20 revealed significant relationship
between comorbidities with misdiagnosis of bipolar disorder (p 0.046).
Conclusion
This study used SCID I instrument as gold standard in diagnosing bipolar
disorder and to find comorbidities. 13.8% respondents were found to be
diagnosed with other than bipolar disorder even after routine medical treatment.
There is a relationship between comorbidity with misdiagnosis of bipolar
disorder., Background
Diagnosing Bipolar Disorder often times has become difficult due to
comorbidities causing indistinct features emerging from the disorder.
Overlapping of bipolar disorder with other psychiatric disorders leads to
inaccuracy since the beginning of diagnosis. Thus people with bipolar disorder
has been diagnosed with other disorders previously.Data fromNational
Depressive and Manic Depressive Association (NDMDA) shows 60% of bipolar
disorder being diagnosed with depression, 26% with anxiety, 18% with
skizofrenia 17% with borderline or antisocial personality disorder, 14% with
alcohol abuse and 11%with schizoaffective. Approximately 69%-73% patients
with bipolar disorder experienced inaccuracy of diagnosis in the beginning.The
author would like to find comorbidities of people with bipolar disorder and its
relationship with misdiagnosis of bipolar diagnosis.
Method
This is an analytic descriptive study with cross sectional in design. Respondents
are adults patients at National Referal Hospital of dr Cipto Mangunkusumo in
Jakarta and dr. Marzoeki Mahdi Hospital in Bogor on Desember 2014, and a
total of 80 samples were acquired. Patients on medication and observed to be
with mood symptoms were performed evaluation from medical record and SCID 1
instrument.
Result
From medical record evaluation, 11 (13.8%) out 80 respondents with bipolar
disorder were found to be diagnosed with other than bipolar disorder after
routine medical treatment. This study found 62.5% from all respondents to have
comorbidities. Analysis using SPSS version 20 revealed significant relationship
between comorbidities with misdiagnosis of bipolar disorder (p 0.046).
Conclusion
This study used SCID I instrument as gold standard in diagnosing bipolar
disorder and to find comorbidities. 13.8% respondents were found to be
diagnosed with other than bipolar disorder even after routine medical treatment.
There is a relationship between comorbidity with misdiagnosis of bipolar
disorder.]