Artikel Jurnal :: Kembali

Artikel Jurnal :: Kembali

Meta-analysis of optimal management of lower pole stone of 10-20 mm: flexible ureteroscopy (furs) versus extracorporeal shock wave lithotripsy (eswl) versus percutaneus nephrolithotomy (pcnl)

oleh Prahara Yuri ... [and others] (Interna Publishing, 2018)

 Abstrak

Baground: the optimal management of lower calyceal stones is still controversial, because no single method is suitable for the removal of all lower calyceal stones. Minimally invasive procedures such as extracorporeal shock wave lithotrispy (ESWL), percutaneous nephrolithotomy (PNCL) and flexible ureteroscopy (fURS) are the therapautic methods for lower calyceal stones. the aim of this study was to identify the optimal management of 10-20 mm lower pole stones.
Methods : a meta-analysis of cohort studies published before July 2016 was performed from Medline and Cochrane databases. Management of 10-20 mm lower pole stone treated by fURS, ESWL and PCNL with follow-up of residual stones in 1-3 months after procedure were include and urinary stone in other location and size were exclude. A fixed-effects model with Mantzel-Haenzel method was used to calculate the I2 statistic. All analyses were performed with review manager 5.3.
Result : we analized 8 cohort studies. The stone free rate from 958 patient (271 PCNL, 174 fURS and 513 ESWL), 3 months after operation, was 90.8% (246/271) after PCNL; 75.3% (131/174) after fURS; and 64.7% (332/513)after ESWL. Base on stone free rate in 10-20 mm lower pole stone following management, PCNL is better than fURS (overall RR was 1.32 (95% CI 1.13-1.55) ; p<0.001 and I2=57%) and ESWL (overall risk ratio 1.42 (95% CI.30-1.55); p=<0.001 and I2=85%). But if we compare between fURS and ESWL, fURS is better than ESWL base on stone free rate in 10-20 mm lower pole stone management with overall RR 1.16 (95% CI 1.04-1.30; p=0.01 and I2=40%).
Conclusion: percutaneous nephrolithotomy provided a higher stone free rate than fURS and ESWL. This meta-analysis may help urologist in makin decision of intervention in 10-20mm lower pole stone management.

 Metadata

Jenis Koleksi : Artikel Jurnal
No. Panggil : 610 IJIM 50:1 (2018)
Entri tambahan-Nama orang :
Penerbitan : Jakarta: Interna Publishing, 2018
Sumber Pengatalogan : LibUI eng rda
ISSN : 01259326
Majalah/Jurnal : The Indonesian Journal of Internal Medicine
Volume : Vol. 50, No. 1, Januari 2018: Hlm. 18-25
Tipe Konten : text
Tipe Media : unmediated
Tipe Carrier : volume
Akses Elektronik :
Institusi Pemilik : Universitas Indonesia
Lokasi : Perpustakaan UI, Lantai 4, R. Koleksi Jurnal
  • Ketersediaan
  • Ulasan
  • Sampul
No. Panggil No. Barkod Ketersediaan
610 IJIM 50:1 (2018) 03-18-332469914 TERSEDIA
Ulasan:
Tidak ada ulasan pada koleksi ini: 20470680
Cover